Aid to Africa

Somaliland says “thanks, but no thanks” to foreign aid

(February  6, 2014) Somaliland – the, unrecognized, self-declared state north of war-torn Somalia – attributes a lack of foreign aid to its success.

By Brady Yauch for Probe International

No foreign aid? No problem.

That’s the message from Somaliland – the, unrecognized, self-declared state that sits north of war-torn Somalia.

Without a seat at the UN, Somaliland is ineligible for foreign aid. “That is a blessing in disguise. Aid never developed anything,” Hussein Abdi Dualeh, Somaliland’s minister of energy and minerals, told Reuters.

“Aid is not a panacea, we’d rather not have it … How many African countries do you know that developed because of a lot of aid? It’s a curse. The ones that get the most aid are the ones with the problems.”

It’s not the first time Somaliland has made the headlines for the right reasons: a functioning democracycompetitive markets and a government that relies on a healthy and open tax system to support itself.

In contrast Somaliland’s southern neighbour, Somalia, has suffered through more than two decades of civil war, is overrun with terrorists and has little to show for the billions of dollars in foreign aid it has received. In 2011 alone, Somalia took in $1.1 billion (US) in foreign aid, according to World Bank data. In 2009 and 2010, Bank auditors could account for only a fraction of the monies it loaned to Somalia. And the country ranks dead last on Transparency International’s corruption index, alongside Afghanistan and North Korea.

Back in Somaliland, Hussein Abdi Dualeh told Reuters, “we’ve been left to our own devices. We are our own people and our own guys. We pull ourselves up by our own boot straps.”

Because his country cannot access international capital markets it also has no debt as a result.

“We owe absolutely nothing to anybody. We would not change hands with Greece today. We have zero debt,” said Hussein Abdi Dualeh, proud of his country’s self-reliance.

Somaliland’s success can be attributed to well functioning local governments that find common cause in setting sound economic policies. But it can also be attributed to its freedom from the foreign aid curse that has been the result of its enforced self-reliance.

Brady Yauch is an economist at Probe International. 

2 replies »

  1. I think that argument made as far as foreign aid is correct, but what you fail to examine is the politics of the situation and history. Somaliland has achieved these results while actively supporting terrorist in the south to justify its separation. It was found that Dahabshiil, which is the largest money transfer network, was sending money to terrorist. This is only further enforced, by the lack of attacks in Somaliland, which isn’t very far from “main land” Somalia. I think this is an oversimplification, and somalia has experience growth , albeit it can’t be measure due to most of it being in the extralegal markets.

  2. Your comment requires evidence, “it was found that Dahabshiil”…who made the finding? Dahabshiil is a company which has more financial operations outside of Somaliland then within. Is the international community responsible for terrorism against Somalia-Italia? As far as lack of attacks in Somaliland 1. 99% of shabab are from Somalia-Italia it is a home grown entity, one which your former president Sheikh-Shariff was a 9year leader to and your current president hassan-Sheikh keeps on his payrole. 2. The Security apparatus in Somaliland is far more suffisticated with fuk support of the population, everyone is invested in keeping the peace, funny enough the population, government and especially your police in somalia-Italia are party to 99% of the terror attacks in your country. The proximity of Somaliland to Somalia-Italia is non issue Kenya is closer to you and so is Ethiopia and neither are afflicted with chronic terrorism. As for claims of growth all the worlds horses and all the worlds men cannot put your umpty loathe-sum state together again. Keep blaming others for your failure see where that gets you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s